Unlock the Mystery: The Best Murder Mystery Costumes For… | You Dunnit (2023)

Oh, the suspense! If you're a fan of solving puzzles, trying to decipher clues, and staying up late with friends trying to uncover the answers to mysterious questions, then a murder mystery party is definitely for you! Whether you’re planning a night of intrigue for yourself and a few friends, or for a larger event, executing the perfect mystery party is as easy as pie - if you have the perfect costumes. And that’s exactly what we’re exploring today – the best murder mystery costumes that’ll have your guests stylishly sleuthing around the room in search of the murderer! So without further ado, let's unlock the mystery and find the perfect outfit that’ll make your next shindig the talk of the town.

Quick Insight

You can find murder mystery costumes online at various costume stores and retailers. If you prefer to shop in person, visit your local party supply store for pre-made options or costume shops for custom-made styles.

1920s-1940s Classic Detective Costumes

When it comes to classic detective costumes, nothing quite beats the era of the 1920s-1940s. With great detectives such as Sherlock Holmes and Nick Charles, this era has become iconic for its mysterious charm and clever storylines. An added bonus to this style of costume is that there are dozens of options available today which can make it easy to recreate the look of a classic detective from any one of these decades. For example, an iconic look could be achieved with a simple combination of a long trench coat, fedora, and magnifying glass.

On the other hand, some may argue that such a timeless look often appears clichéd or outdated. While it's true that many modern murder mystery events lean towards more contemporary styles, there are still plenty of people who appreciate the flair of by-gone eras with their classy style and nuances. As such, a classic detective costume can still bring in an air of nostalgia while maintaining its relevance within the setting.

Adding accessories to complete the look is an integral part of putting together any classic detective costume from the 1920s-1940s era. Anything from a deerstalker hat to a pipe will do nicely to bring out the discerning eye of your inner-sleuth. And now for our next section: accessories to complete the look!

  • According to data collected in 2019, the top 5 most popular murder mystery costumes of the year were detective, zombie, Mafia-type gangster, creepy clown, and femme fatale (or vixen).
  • A survey conducted in 2020 revealed that more than 40% of people buying murder mystery costumes for Halloween prefer a classic look like Sherlock Holmes or Agatha Christie.
  • A survey from 2020 also found that 90% of those who purchased murder mystery costumes reported feeling more immersed in the experience after wearing them.

Main Points to Remember

The classic detective costumes of the 1920s-1940s, with iconic detectives such as Sherlock Holmes and Nick Charles, are still popular today. Although they may be considered clichéd or outdated, they remain relevant in certain settings. Complete the look with accessories like a deerstalker hat, pipe, trench coat, fedora, and magnifying glass to bring out your inner sleuth.

Accessories to Complete the Look

Accessories can complete the look of a costume and put the final touches on any evening’s mysterious fun. There are many creative items that may be used to make your perfect murder mystery ensemble come together, such as wigs, fake glasses frames, hats, mustaches, shoes, and more.

When considering what accessories to choose for your evening attire, it is important to consider the impact of each piece on the overall look of your character. Too much accessorizing can make an individual appear overdressed or stuffy in comparison to the event's other guests. On the other hand, too few accessories can make a person look unfinished while also making them indistinguishable from the rest of the crowd. Therefore, one should consider conservatively accessorizing their character in order to achieve and envious mixture of stylishness and individuality.

(Video) How to host a murder mystery dinner party

Another point to consider is comfort level when picking out accessories. While certain items may look fashionable and fit with the theme of the night, one should only pick pieces that they feel comfortable wearing for a long period of time. This will ensure for an enjoyable evening for all involved without compromise in fashion choices.

To summarize, when considering accessory choices for your next murder mystery party, think carefully about how each item could complement or detract from your overall appearance. Consider selecting just a few key pieces that will establish who you are meant supposed to be playing but also ensure maximum comfort levels are achieved during the course of the evening. Now that we have discussed some accessories tips for a great night ahead let’s move onto “Mysterious Whodunit Costume Ideas”, where we will take a closer look at some great costume suggestions for your upcoming murder mystery celebration.

Mysterious Whodunit Costume Ideas

Mysterious whodunit costumes are a great way to add a level of intrigue to your next murder mystery party. As everyone arrives, they can get into the spirit of the game and help uncover clues to determine who did it. Even if you don’t have an entire costume already planned out, you can dress in simple items and still fit the theme.

Choosing items that are both mysterious and comfortable will be important so design a look that best works for you. Many people opt for dressing up as detectives or secret agents to blend in with others who may be wearing more classic detective costumes. You could also go for something more abstract like a dark-colored suit with a fedora and a fake mustache. A trench coat over all black is also an easy go-to option that still screams classic mystery novel.

On the other hand, those who want to opt for something less conventional may consider finding costume elements from popular books or movies such as Sherlock Holmes, The Maltese Falcon, or Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple series. These styles often feature dapper accessories like bowties, colorful vests, and striking hats that harken back to old school detective look.

Regardless of which route you decide to take, remember to have fun with it! Your friends will likely enjoy seeing each person show off their own unique take on a whodunit costume.

Check out our suggestions for Christmas and Halloween murder mystery parties.

Now it’s time to provide clothing and props that guests can inspect at the party in order to unravel clues hidden throughout the night.

Clothing and Props to Inspect

When attending a murder mystery event, clothing and props are essential for getting into character. As the host, it is your responsibility to provide guests with everything they need to be successful sleuths and actors.

(Video) Murder Mystery Dinner Party (What to Do)

One of the most important items to consider for an amazing murder mystery costume is a magnifying glass prop. This accessory gives detectives a classic look that evokes thoughts of mysterious mysteries, serious crime investigations, and spooky evenings. For added fun, you can hide clues in the form of hidden pictures or messages throughout the party space. Clues can be scattered in plain view to add some extra challenge.

Although they are certainly not necessary, top hats and monocles can add a lot of class to any mysterious evening. For those looking to go all out, old-fashioned trench coats with fedoras will help capture the feeling of mystery and intrigue that comes with these types of events. Costumes can also be completed with facial hair, jewelry pieces that resemble clues, or even tiny detective notebooks!

It is essential that these elements work together and fit into the overall theme of the event. While some people may prefer more subtle details, others might want outrageous pieces like kooky wigs or big mustaches to really bring their characters to life. Debate aside, clothing and props should be coordinated so that each guest is prepared to take on their detective persona without flaunting any standout costumes that could take away from team play.

No matter what type of clothing and props you choose for your murder mystery event, it is important to make sure everyone feels comfortable in their costume before the game begins. With this in mind, let's move on to discussing some fun and mysterious murder mystery costumes that can be used as inspiration when preparing for your next game night!

Fun and Mysterious Murder Mystery Costumes

Fun and Mysterious Murder Mystery Costumes can be a great way to get your guests into the spooky summer spirit. A creative, carefully chosen costume can often make the difference between a mediocre soiree and one that is remembered fondly for years to come!

On one hand, specialty shops often contain a large selection of pre-made costumes that are Halloween themed but still unique. Many of these costumes even come with their own accessories like wigs and prosthetics! However, if you’re looking for something that stands out from the crowd -- or something tailored to the particular theme of your murder mystery party -- then consider creating your own.

Making your own costume takes a bit more effort and imagination than buying a pre-packaged outfit. You may need to hit the thrift stores or scour fabric stores for materials, or spend hours stitching together pieces you've bought into something eye-catching. However, when done properly, the results can be well worth it as your guest’s will turn up in costume which suit the individual character they play in the game perfectly.

No matter which direction you take, have fun creating unique and mysterious costumes that are sure to be the talk of your next murder mystery party! Now onto creating your own characters...

Create Your Own Character

Creating your own murder mystery costume can be a fun and creative way to take part in the festivities. Depending on how much time and resources you have available, you may choose to build your costume from scratch or to purchase a pre-made one.

(Video) You Dunnit 2020 Promo

Constructing the costume yourself allows you to customize the look, creating something unique that nobody else will have at your event. You will need to source out materials to make sure everything comes together as planned, so plan ahead of time by researching potential looks online or flipping through fashion magazines for inspiration. You'll also need accessories such as hats, masks, jewelry and props to complete the look. Having a few costume pieces on hand can be helpful when it comes to dressing up for any event; if you're feeling particularly creative and crafty, you could always sew or glue pieces together as well!

Alternatively, pre-made costumes are often more affordable and convenient than making one from scratch. They come with everything you'll need already assembled, so all you have to do is slip them on and go. Many stores even offer custom-made pieces if you're looking for something unique that's not off-the-rack.

Regardless of which route you choose to go with your costume, remember to have fun with it! Whatever look you come up with should be appropriate for the occasion, but don't be afraid express your personality too – after all, that's what makes a costume stand out.

Now that you know how to make or obtain a murder mystery costume, let's explore where exactly you can find them: in this next section we’ll discuss where to get murder mystery costumes.

Where to Get Murder Mystery Costumes

When planning your next murder mystery party, shopping for the perfect costumes is essential. Whether you’re looking for ready-made pieces or creating your own from items that you have laying around, everyone should have a complete and unique look for the evening.

One of the main advantages to finding pre-made costumes is that they tend to be easier and quicker to assemble — especially if you don’t already know how to sew. Many costume stores carry generic types of costume pieces such as hats, dress shirts, suspenders, and more that could easily be pieced together. However, if you choose to go this route, it could end up being more expensive than making clothes by hand. Plus, when selecting standard costume items like tuxedos and evening gowns, they may not fit you correctly and could lack the detail needed to achieve an authentic look.

For those who prefer creativity and would rather opt for a DIY approach, designing your own costumes can be a lot of fun and offers much more flexibility when it comes to price. Shopping for fabric at thrift stores can be extremely affordable — many places even offer a “99 cents per pound” deal — and creating something from scratch allows each person to get exactly what they want in terms of style and fit. It also allows everyone in attendance to have truly unique looks without worry about running into someone with the same ensemble.

Though both methods come with their pros and cons, creating authentic murder mystery costumes can be done either way with just a bit of time and effort. With that said, it's time to move on to understanding how to act like a detective at the party — which means becoming proficient in questioning suspects and finding clues!

How to Act Like a Detective at the Party

One of the best parts about a murder mystery party is getting to be a detective and solve the case. But that doesn’t mean you just need to come in dressed as Sherlock Holmes and do nothing else! With the right attitude, some preparation and a few helpful hints, you can really bring out your inner sleuth.

(Video) Whodunit Crime Mystery Movie - Murder At Midnight (1931)

The first step is choosing how you will portray your character. Stick with the basics: take a look at classic detective films like “Sherlock Holmes”, “Columbo” or “Agatha Christie's Poirot” for inspiration. Decide whether you want to be more of an active sleuth or an observant one, and make sure you practice both types of behavior.

As far as acting goes, refrain from overdoing it. You are playing a detective so try to remain cool, calm and collected throughout the party even when things become tense. It helps to think of yourself as just another guest who happens to have an eye for details - like noticing when someone is behaving strangely or tracking down clues as they pop up throughout the night. Of course it also helps to practice your deductive skills ahead of time - reading up on police procedures or doing an online investigation course could give you an edge over the other detectives at the party.

On that note, pay attention not only to what people are saying but also to what they aren’t saying. Detectives need to be able to decipher body language, tones of voice and other subtle clues in order to help them draw their conclusions. As always, trust your instincts - if something doesn’t feel quite right then don’t ignore it! And when it comes time for everyone at the party to make their cases, don’t be afraid to challenge any theories put forth by both your fellow detectives and the suspects!

At the end of the day, remember that this is all supposed to be fun. Have a good laugh with your friends, enjoy the acting and revel in solving the case together - that's really all there is to being a successful detective at a murder mystery party!

Conclusion: Perfect Costume for a Murder Mystery Party: Now that you know how to act like a detective during your next murder mystery party, it's time to find just the right costume! The costume should keep in mind both practicality (since after all you do still have to be able to move around freely while investigating) as well as style (because let's face it, part of being a true detective is looking ones' part!). Read on explore some great ideas for costumes that will make your night one full of mystery!

Conclusion: Perfect Costume for a Murder Mystery Party

When it comes to the perfect costume for a murder mystery party, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The best costume choice is ultimately dependent on the setting and theme of the party, as well as the style of play chosen by the hosts. However, there are some tried and true classic choices that can help guests feel like they are truly part of their fictional world of intrigue.

For example, women should consider dressy gowns with a subtle color scheme that reflects the era of the game’s setting. To add a whimsical touch, accessorize with magnifying glasses or other detective-themed attire. Men should look for stylish suits in earth or jewel tones that are appropriate for their character. For an added level of enjoyment, have each guest adopt a persona associated with their chosen outfit.

In addition to time period and personal flair considerations, gamers should be mindful when selecting props or accessories that could prove distracting during play. Incorporating too many large items or bulky items into one’s ensemble may hinder activity or impede interactions between guests throughout the game.

Ultimately, every guest should craft their murder mystery costume in a way that adds to the immersive experience without being too cumbersome or disruptive. With careful planning and collaboration among attendees, your next murder mystery gathering is sure to be remembered by all!

Answers to Commonly Asked Questions

What styles of costumes are best suited for a murder mystery party?

The best murder mystery costumes for a party should be as creative, detailed and immersive as possible. Incorporate elements of specific time periods, characters or locations that are central to the plot. For instance, if your party takes place in the 1920s during the height of speakeasy culture, opt for flapper dresses and pinstripe suits to create an authentic look. If your mystery involves supernatural creatures or otherworldly elements, get creative with accessories and makeup. Whatever approach you take, keeping the theme in mind will ensure your guests have a memorable experience.


How do I create an authentic murder mystery costume on a budget?

Creating an authentic murder mystery costume on a budget can be tricky, but it is possible. A great way to accomplish this is to start with the basics, like black pants and shoes, and then build up your outfit with a variety of accessories. Look for props that are both inexpensive and easy to find, such as old fedora hats, monocles, masks, bow ties and vintage jewelry. Thrift stores and second-hand shops are also great places to find items for your costume at a low price. If you're feeling creative, try shopping at craft stores for fabric and other materials to use to make your own props or accessories. With some imagination, you can put together an authentic murder mystery costume without breaking the bank.

Where are the best places to buy murder mystery costumes?

When it comes to finding the best places to buy murder mystery costumes for your next party, there are a few options. You can find great deals online from well-known costume retailers, or you can check out thrift stores or local costume shops for more unique items. Online retailers often offer a wide selection of costumes in all sizes, so you’re sure to find something suitable for everyone. If budget is an issue, skip the expensive specialty stores and shop at thrift stores for vintage pieces that can be modified or re-purposed for the perfect murder mystery costume. And finally, don’t forget about local costume shops – they will have a mix of both affordable items as well as higher-end pieces that won’t necessarily break the bank.


What is the dress code for murder mystery? ›

DRESS CODE: Business casual/dressy casual is required unless specified. No logo/printed T-shirts, shorts, ballcaps, flip-flops, or torn clothes are permissible. Jeans are acceptable unless specified. MINIMUM AGE: Minimum age varies by location; please visit each location's FAQ page for specific details.

How to dress for a murder mystery night? ›

No there's no dress code but I'd suggest you go comfortable clean casual.

Which murder mystery box is the best? ›

Our List of the Top Murder Mystery Game Boxes
  1. Unsolved Case Files. ...
  2. Death At The Dive Bar. ...
  3. Murder Mystery On The Night Train. ...
  4. The Moon Summit by Hunt A Killer. ...
  5. 1920s Speakeasy Murder Mystery. ...
  6. Tabletop Escape Room Game. ...
  7. Murder On The Mystery Express – Team Building Event. ...
  8. A Killing Affair.
Jul 20, 2022

How to have a murder mystery Halloween party? ›

How to host a Halloween murder mystery party
  1. Choose Virtual or IRL murder mystery game style.
  2. Choose a murder mystery party theme.
  3. Send themed invitations.
  4. Assign murder mystery characters.
  5. Decide on the event space.
  6. Plan the Halloween party menu.
  7. Decide on spooky drinks.
  8. Decorate the space in all things halloween.
Sep 6, 2022

Is there codes in murder mystery? ›

There are currently no working codes for Muder Mystery 2. Though check back regularly as we'll be sure to update this page as we find them!

Is there anything inappropriate in murder mystery? ›

A few mild sexual jokes. A fully clothed man and woman attempt to have sex. All efforts consist of them rolling around on the bed, but they are interrupted and no actual sex is seen. Many females wear revealing clothing.

What is a cozy style mystery? ›

Cozy mystery is a sub-genre of crime fiction, where sex, violence, and cursing are kept to a minimum, and often happen off stage. The tone of cozies is generally light, comedic, and comforting.

How do you dress like a detective? ›

As mentioned above, if you haven't got a suit, you can simply wear some trousers, a plain top and cover yourself with a trench coat. A light brown is usually a common detective's choice, but you can find plenty of cheap trench coats in your local clothing stores or online.

Does the Mystery Box ever go away? ›

The Mystery Box closes itself after it's used once. The only way to open it again is to wait a set amount of time, and then send another Pokémon to Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! or Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee!

Does the mystery box go away? ›

In Pokémon GO

The Meltan will stop appearing after the box's timer has expired. The Mystery Box will then remain shut on a three-day countdown timer. Once the countdown reaches zero, the player can unlock the box again by transferring Pokémon from GO to Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu!, Let's Go, Eevee!

How do you make a Who dunnit? ›

Key Points When Writing A Whodunnit
  1. Establish the protagonist and his/her relation with the crime.
  2. Establish the antagonist's motive.
  3. Research the geographical-historical setting and use it to feed the plot.
  4. Plant some clues along the way.
Aug 6, 2019

How long should a murder mystery party last? ›

A typical murder mystery game lasts about 2-3 hours (depending on how many people are playing). As host, you'll be responsible for handing out clues, stopping and starting the DVD or CD (if there is one), and making sure everyone has asked/answered all their questions in each round.

How do you get mythics in murder party on Roblox? ›

These cosmetics can be earned via boxes, daily rewards, and limited time purchases that can be bought in the shop or purchased with Robux. However, mythic cosmetics can only be obtained via The Limited Time Store or certain Boxes.

How do you get Nik's Scythe? ›

Nik's Scythe is an ancient knife given to players who helped report bugs to Nikilis or close friends of him. There is no way to obtain it besides being one of Nikilis' friends (given personally by Nikilis through a code entered in-game).

What is the code for MM2 2022? ›

D3NIS - Redeem this code to receive a free dark blue knife. CORL - Redeem this code to receive a free blue knife. SK3TCH - Redeem this code to receive a free orange knife. PRISM - Redeem this code to receive a free silver knife.

What are some MM2 codes that are not expired? ›

February 13, 2023: we checked for new MM2 codes. Do you enjoy a good whodunnit or getting to the bottom of a mysterious crime?
Here are the latest Murder Mystery 2 codes
  • INF3CT3D.
  • G003Y.
  • R3PT1L3.
  • SK00L.
  • PATR1CK.
  • 2015.
  • G1FT3D.
  • TH3N3XTL3V3L.
7 days ago

Is a 11 year old allowed to watch Stranger Things? ›

What's the Stranger Things Age Rating? First, it's worth noting that the maker of Stranger Things, Netflix, has rated it TV-14. That means they don't think it's appropriate for anyone under 14 to watch it.

What are the cuss words in murder mystery? ›

Language includes both cursing ("s--t," "d--k," "t-t," "ass," "pr--k") and sexual jokes ("getting laid," "the boat does all the work"), along with sexual conversations (about waning marital sex, infidelity, and more).

Is the glass onion OK for kids? ›

The film is suitable for teens and up. Glass Onion features more sexual content than its predecessor, with a couple laying in bed and making out while wearing bathing suits. This scene is shown twice. Sex toys and sexual references are present as well.

What is a COSY crime? ›

a genre of crime fiction that is relatively gentle and lighthearted, with little or no graphic or gruesome detail.

What does vampires eat? ›

In addition to blood, vampires have been thought to consume other essences of the human body, including thoughts, saliva, and fluids exchanged during sexual activity. While all vampires need to consume blood, some depictions of vampires reject the idea of hurting or killing humans, so they drink the blood of animals.

How to have a vampire look? ›

Use dark eyeliner.
  1. Apply eyeliner and use a small amount of dark purple eye shadow with black mascara. ...
  2. Light red eye shadow around the eyes is also good. ...
  3. For a more dramatic look, use darker eye shadow on the top of your eyes, and lighter eye shadow underneath your eyes.

How do vampires look? ›

Vampires were usually reported as bloated in appearance, and ruddy, purplish, or dark in colour; these characteristics were often attributed to the recent drinking of blood, which was often seen seeping from the mouth and nose when one was seen in its shroud or coffin, and its left eye was often open.

How do you dress like an undercover spy? ›

A spy or secret agent costume can be as easy as wearing a long coat in black, gray, or even camel, buttoned up or belted with a pair of boots and sunglasses. Add a hat, gloves, and red lips for more details.

What pants do detectives wear? ›

Police detectives do not wear uniforms, but they do have a kind of dress code. Most police detectives wear suits. Plainclothes detectives wear business casual options, but they typically wear slacks and jackets, depending on the season.

How do you dress like a Death Eater? ›

Cosplay the Death Eater's evil look by wearing a Death Eater's Mask, Black Pants, and Victorian Jacket. Add to the mystery by wearing a Black Cloak, Leather Wrist Bands, and Black Shoes.

What do you wear to a Mystery Room? ›

Although there is no strict dress code for an escape room, we recommend that you wear comfortable clothing and comfortable shoes. You will be moving around a lot, so it is important to be able to move freely. We also recommend avoiding loose or flowing clothing as it might get caught on something in the room.

How should a detective dress up? ›

As mentioned above, if you haven't got a suit, you can simply wear some trousers, a plain top and cover yourself with a trench coat. A light brown is usually a common detective's choice, but you can find plenty of cheap trench coats in your local clothing stores or online.

What do you wear to a masquerade murder mystery? ›

Evening wear, ball gowns, Venetian masks, suits, and tuxes are what to wear to this high class night of masks and murder.

What can I expect at a murder mystery dinner party? ›

You'll have to use your detective skills to piece together who did it. This might involve interrogating other guests, examining the crime scene, and paying close attention to the clues provided. At the end of the evening, the host will work with the detectives to solve the crime and identify the culprit.


1. Murder Mystery Game Show | Game Changer [Full Episode]
2. Comedy Mystery Movie - Inspector Hornleigh (1939)
3. Adrian Prout: Narcissist Who Thought He’d Never Get Caught | World's Most Evil Killers | True Crime
(FilmRise True Crime)
4. Mystery 101 | Pilot
5. Crime Mystery Movie - A Night for Crime (1943)
6. MURDER MYSTERY CHOOSE YOUR OWN STORY| A Royal High Extravaganza -may contain bad stuff-
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gregorio Kreiger

Last Updated: 01/23/2023

Views: 5544

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gregorio Kreiger

Birthday: 1994-12-18

Address: 89212 Tracey Ramp, Sunside, MT 08453-0951

Phone: +9014805370218

Job: Customer Designer

Hobby: Mountain biking, Orienteering, Hiking, Sewing, Backpacking, Mushroom hunting, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Gregorio Kreiger, I am a tender, brainy, enthusiastic, combative, agreeable, gentle, gentle person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.